I wrote a letter in support of a friend last night, who is being sentenced to federal prison in less than a month. The letter was a plea for leniency. In it, I described the better points of her character and tried to explain what could have motivated her to do what she did.
It’s an emotional time. I’ve known my friend for 10 years. I never knew that she was involved in some of the things for which she’s now being sentenced, but looking back at the time during which I met her, it makes sense. She’s a compassionate individual, and the crimes she committed are the sort of things a strong-minded person in their twenties, with a passion for protecting those who can’t protect themselves, might be motivated to do.
She was involved in some actions with an environmental group about a decade ago that resulted in some serious property damage, but not, as far as I can tell, any loss of or injury to human life. That seems to have been one of her group’s principles. Apparently, some of the facilities they took action against were owned by companies that were using them for some pretty heinous acts – rounding up wild horses from public lands and rendering them for meat, for example. But though this may have been bad, her group’s actions were considered the more illegal. She did a pretty good job of keeping these things quiet and unknown to her friends outside of that group and her family, and apparently she thought she had left that part of her life behind long ago.
It caught up with her, with a vengeance. Someone in her group eventually informed on the rest of them, and by the time they caught up with her, they had enough evidence to put her away for life. Given that choice vs. helping the investigators in exchange for a lesser sentence, she chose to help. It must have been a gut-wrenching decision for her, as some of the people she was asked to give evidence on had been her friends. I don’t like to think about what I would have done, or how I would have felt, in the same situation. Fortunately, I have nothing in my past that would ever put me in that same situation, but still.
In the past few weeks I have read more hate-spewing stuff on the internet than I have ever seen associated with anyone I knew. There are news articles describing her in harsh terms as a felon and eco-terrorist, whose authors wonder how such a nice young girl with such a promising future could have taken such a wrong turn. Some of the more negative comments I’ve read with these articles say that she should just be locked up for life, or killed, or worse.
I’m not defending her actions. But sometimes, caring, compassionate individuals, especially when young, can take their enthusiasm for justice a bit too far. While some choose to heal the evils of society in a more measured, steady way, some choose a more abrupt route. What I’m saying is that she’s not an evil person – as far as I can tell, her actions were motivated by a desire to protect wildlife and the environment, not for personal gain or personal vengeance. She discontinued doing these things long ago, and now understands that these actions were not only wrong, but may have damaged her causes more than helped them.
The sad thing is, the worst stuff I’ve read about her has been on environmental activist sites, where she is reviled as a snitch. There, people are calling her a traitor to their cause and posting photos of her so that she can be identified on sight to anyone who might wish to do her harm. I find this sort of knee-jerk reaction to be as bad as the people who automatically revile her for committing her acts in the first place.
It’s different when you know the person. It’s easy to look at a person you don’t know who has committed a crime, and assume all kinds of things about them that justify your hatred of their actions and allow you to hate them as well. It’s not so easy to give a person you don’t know the benefit of the doubt.
The person I know is a caring, compassionate individual who sometimes goes out of her way to help the people she loves. I’ve known her as a loyal friend and a bright, intelligent person who I’ve been happy to have in my life. It saddens me deeply to see her going off to jail, though I understand that, karmically and otherwise, it’s what has to happen. I don’t think of her differently, even though I wouldn’t have done what she did. I see her as a friend who went a little too far in expressing her sense of justice, by taking matters into her own hands.
If anything, this experience teaches me to think of anyone I read about in the news, who has committed some sort of crime with which I disagree, as a person with a life and a past, who may or may not have good qualities that I may never know about. The age-old wisdom that you should hate the sin, but not the sinner, seems to apply here. I wish I could teach that to the people on both sides who simply want to judge her based on what little they know, instead of understanding her as a whole person.